C. Stephen Layman’s essay, ‘Why be a superhero? Why be Moral?’ provides a good discussion on the topic of morality. Do you agree?
The concept of morality stems from the idea of what is considered right and wrong. C. Stephen Layman explores this concept in his essay ‘Why be a superhero? Why be moral?’ Morality is defined as being ‘ethical wisdom’ or having the ability to determine between right and wrong duties. His essay discusses a main idea of morality, that of good versus evil, as well as producing understandable rebuttals to his own arguments and connecting morality with a modern idea, superheroes. These factors contribute to the easily understandable and relatable tone of the entire discussion.
The essay provides a good discussion on the issue of morality because it incorporates common, yet powerful arguments of why one should be moral. The first of these is good versus evil, indicated in his first reason; “Reason One: If you fail to do your moral duty, there will be negative consequences that affect you directly or indirectly.” This explores the idea that if a person is able to perform moral duty, and they don’t, then bad or “evil” things will happen to you. It also imposes the idea that although “with great power comes great responsibility” it can also bring with it “self satisfaction”. The essay also mentions the idea that peace of mind is only possible if people are moral in “Reason Two: Doing your duty is the only way you can have harmony in your soul (roughly, peace of mind)”. This is a value that was explored by Plato and is another idea of morality that proves Layman’s discussion of morality as plausible.
The layout of Layman’s essay establishes the fact that his discussion of morality is outstanding. After each of his five reasons for being moral, he introduces a contrasting argument for each. This stays true to discussion form, yet it also allows the audience to understand the concepts of morality from both side of the spectrum,...